Citation for this: Efendi, F., Chen, C. M., Kurniati, A., Nursalam, N., & Yusuf, A. THE SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS OF NURSING EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE IN INDONESIA. Malaysian Journal of Nursing. 2018
THE SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS OF NURSING EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE IN INDONESIA
Volume-9, Issue 4, 2018, Pages 0 – 0
Ferry Efendi 1; Ching-Min Chen 2 ; Anna Kurniati 3; Nursalam. M 4; Ah. Yusuf 5;
1Faculty of Nursing, Universitas Airlangga, Surabaya, Indonesia
2Professor, Department of Nursing, Institute of Gerontology, Institute of Allied Health Sciences, College of Medicine, National Cheng Kung University, Tainan, Taiwan
3Center for Planning and Management of Human Resources for Health, BPPSDMK, Ministry of Health, Indonesia
4Professor, Faculty of Nursing, Universitas Airlangga, Surabaya, Indonesia
5Faculty of Nursing, Universitas Airlangga, Surabaya, Indonesia
Background: The Indonesian nursing workforce plays an important role in the nation’s health development. However, the Ministry of Health of Indonesia acknowledges that there is a shortage in the nursing cadre. This situation is at odds with the current large-scale production of nurses occurring in Indonesia.
Aim: This article aims to analyse the latest situation of nursing education and nursing workforce in Indonesia and the challenges faced by the profession.
Methods: This study is literature review emphasizing the policy issues and responses on education and workforce. Data were collected from various sources, including the Ministry of Health, other relevant stakeholders, and journals. Document extraction and review was conducted from December 2015 to January 2017.
Results and conclusion: Results indicated that there is a chronic shortage of nurses in certain regions of Indonesia. Current shortages could easily be aggravated by the disequilibrium between supply and demand. Meanwhile, the over production of the nursing workforce in various regions has contributed to the surplus number of nurses. Policy options must be adopted to reduce shortages and with a offering of temporary surplus of nurses is suggested to solve the current issues.
Keywords : Nursing Education, Nursing Workforce, Indonesian Nurses
In the country’s current healthcare landscape, Indonesia started to implement Universal Health Coverage (UHC) from January 2014 (DJSN and MoH, 2012; MoH, 2016b). The execution of UHC needs an adequate and well-performing health workforce as the cornerstone of the nation’s health system (Cometto et al., 2013; Kurniati et al., 2015). However, the quality, availability and distribution of Indonesia’s health workforce in supporting UHC needs to be enhanced (MoH, 2014a; Mboi, 2015). While many countries experience health workforce shortages, Indonesia has been acknowledged as one of the countries suffering the greatest deficit in Asia (World Health Organization, 2006). The recent data published by the World Health Organization in 2014 shows the availability of human resources for health fall below the minimum recommended threshold (World Health Organization, 2014). The Ministry of Health (MoH) also admitted that there is a shortage of health personnel, including the nursing cadre, to serve the health needs of the entire Indonesian population (MoH, 2016b). Government documents showed that, in 2014, there was a shortage of nurses in public hospitals of 10,370 nurses and 4,213 in community health centres(MoH, 2014a). In addition, the projected shortage will worsen to a deficiency of 87,618 nurses in public hospitals, 602 nurses in military hospitals and 20,230 nurses in community health centres by 2019 (Kemenkokesra, 2013). As UHC is implemented, the demand for nurses will increase as the government meets its target for the recommended number of nurses in community health centres of six nurses for those without inpatient services and ten nurses for those with inpatient services (MoH, 2014a).
On the other hand, published documents show an overproduction of nursing graduates and unemployment of nurses (Suwandono et al., 2005; Suara Surabaya, 2013; BNP2TKI, 2016). Recent government analysis by The National Board for Placement and Protection of Indonesian Overseas Workers or BNP2TKI revealed that 31,150 Indonesian nurses were without a job (BNP2TKI, 2016). Further, the available data in 2012 showed 12,000 unemployed nurses in East Java province (Suara Surabaya, 2013; Bappeda Jatim, 2012), and previous national data showed 15,000 nurses were unemployed in 2005 (Suwandono et al., 2005). The limited capacity of the public and private health sectors to employ nurses has been reported as one of the constraints (Suwandono et al., 2005; Kurniati & Efendi, 2013). Indonesia is also at risk of having a surplus number of nurses (Spetz, 2011). Available data showed 35,821 and 34,150 graduates of nursing in 2011 and 2012, respectively were produced by nursing institutions (Ministry of Education and Culture, 2014; MoH, 2011).
Several clear actions have been taken in the past few years, showing the government’s strong commitment to tackle the Human Resources for Health (HRH) crisis (MoH, 2014a; Kurniati et al., 2015). However, progress has been slow despite the need for an essential solution. This article reviews the current situation of the nursing workforce and education in Indonesia and identifies challenges faced by profession.
Research Methodology :
The article reports the results of an extensive review of literature in the form of electronic and printed material on the nursing education and workforce in Indonesia. We purposely searched and analysed relevant information from Google Scholar, ProQuest, and Scopus databases. As a few articles relating to our objective written in English, white papers from the Ministry of Health (MoH), Ministry of Education and Culture (MoEC), Indonesian National Nurses Association (INNA) website, journals, and newspapers written in Bahasa Indonesia were reviewed. Selected articles were collated and appraised among authors to see the relevance. Document extraction and review was conducted from December 2015 to January 2017. A synthesis of policy review information provided structured nursing workforce situation, nursing education, the challenges and the proposal for future agenda.
Nursing in Indonesia has witnessed remarkable advances in the areas of workforce and education. In order to present a comprehensive view of the Indonesian nursing profession, in this section the country’s current situation is described in the history of the nursing profession, nursing workforce and nursing education in Indonesia.
Indonesia is a country of more than 17,000 islands, comprised of 34 provinces and has become one of the world’s most populous countries (Ministry of State Secretariat of the Republic of Indonesia, 2014). Indonesia’s population is 237.6 million, of which, according to the 2010 census, 50% live in urban areas, and 87% are Muslim (Statistics Indonesia – Badan Pusat Statistik – BPS et al., 2013). The life expectancy at birth for males are 68.7 years and 72.6 years for females. The current Maternal Mortality Rate is 359 per 100,000 live births, and the Infant Mortality rate is 32 deaths per 1,000 live births. The literacy rate for 15-24 years old was 96.8% in the year 2012 (Statistics Indonesia – Badan Pusat Statistik – BPS et al., 2013).
The number of nurses rose significantly between 1995 and 2006; however, inequitable distribution and quality of training issues have been reported in some published documents (AIPNI et al., 2012; Anderson et al., 2014). Nurses on the front line in Indonesia’s health system play a critical role in improving the health outcome of the community. According to a World Bank study in 2009, nurses are often the only health staff in remote and hardship areas (Anderson et al., 2014). According to the latest data, an estimated 118.3 million Indonesian live in rural areas (Statistics Indonesia – Badan Pusat Statistik – BPS et al., 2013), and there are still some community health centres that remain unattended by doctor (Anderson et al., 2014). Therefore, nurses will take the lead to improve community health status in hardship areas. As such, we need to pay specific attention to elevating the impact of the nursing profession in the UHC era.
History of the Nursing Profession in Indonesia
The history of nursing in Indonesia cannot easily be tracked as there are no formal published reports on the topic. As stated by a researcher from the Netherlands, the history of healthcare services in Indonesia’s colonial era was neglected (Boomgaard, 1993). As result pre, during and post-colonial era in Indonesia was traced back. Some may say that nursing has existed in Indonesia since the establishment of hospitals. Beginning with the Dutch mission to take over Indonesia through economic means, they were set up by the Dutch East India Company (VOC) to provide a facility to enhance the mission, including the building of the hospital in Batavia (later known as Jakarta). One study noted the nursing development during the colonial era, which placed emphasis on males nurse recruitment in the hospital setting, then spreading out to the community services (Schoute, 1937). Other published sources mentioned that the first hospital in Batavia was opened on 1 July 1926; it was exclusively for the employees of the company (Schoute, 1937). As time went by, the East India Government needed a ward to care for the wounded people. The ward, later known as Stadsverban, was headed by a Dutch doctor with assistance from local people (who probably acted as nurses). The Stadsverban became the blueprint of civil hospitals in the big cities over Java’s island (Schoute, 1937). One policy which contributed to the improvement of the healthcare services was the ethical policy launched by VOC during the colonial era (Fasseur, 2000).
Various nurse organisations were also initiated, either to enhance the profession itself or for propaganda. During the colonisation period, the Dutch nurses acted as nurse educators to be deployed in several big cities across Indonesia, such as Jakarta, Surabaya, and Medan. After independence, Indonesia established various nursing education facilities for elementary school graduates (Sekolah Rakyat) and junior high school graduates. The variation depended on the need of the community, which was more task-oriented, and it was noted that 20 types of nurse cadres were produced at that time (AIPNI et al., 2012). The need for a higher level of nurse education was acknowledged by the Ministry of Health (MoH) when, in 1962, it opened diploma level training. In 1974, at a national meeting on the basic level of nurse education, the Sekolah Perawat Kesehatan (SPK) (senior high school level) was established. SPK was the most popular nursing school in Indonesia until its abolishment in 1998 by the MoH (Ministry of Education and Culture, 2010).
The first National Health System concept was launched in 1982, mandated professional nurses in healthcare services. This led to the establishment of a bachelor degree programme in nursing in 1985. The bachelor degree in nursing was initiated by the University of Indonesia, as a public university, and then followed by other public universities across Indonesia. According to the data from the Ministry of Education and Culture (MoEC), currently, nursing education is at the following levels – diploma, bachelor, master, specialist and doctoral degrees(AIPNI et al., 2012). The higher education section, which was under the MoEC, then transferred to the Ministry of Research, Technology and Higher Education (Kemristekdikti) was formed in 2014.
Nursing Workforce in Indonesia
There is no exact estimate of the number of nurses across Indonesia due to voluntary registration and the lack of human resource information systems in Indonesia (Kurniati and Efendi, 2012). The latest data from the Ministry of Health for 2016 showed that the total number of nurses was 224,035 (MoH, 2016a). However, other data published in 2006 showed that we have 308,306 nurses (MoH, 2007). It must be noted that the data from the MoH may under report since the MoH database includes only those government institutions and private hospitals that send a report to the MoH. The incomplete information on available data of nurses over Indonesia may hinder human resource management planning in national level.
Currently, the country has 889study programmes in nursing, which offer diploma, bachelor, master and doctoral degrees(Ministry of Education and Culture, 2014). This data included schools managed by the Ministry of Health (known as Polytechnics) which operates151 nursing study programme sacross Indonesia. Nurses represent the largest proportion (33.12%) of the total health workforce of Indonesia (MoH, 2014b). Even though there is no agreement on the precise ratio of health workers to population, WHO has identified 2.28 per 1000 populations as the “threshold” density of the three cadres (doctors, nurses, and midwives) with a range from 2.02 to 2.54 (Speybroeck et al., 2006). Particular reference for nurses showed the ratio of nurses to population at 0.2 per 1000 population (20 per 100,000) (World Bank, 1993).
According to the government document, the ratio of nurses to population was 96.2 nurses per 100,000 population (MoH, 2013), meaning that the country is over the threshold by having 0.96 nurses per 1000 population. As noted by the government of Indonesia, the distribution ofthe health workforce, including nurses, does not follow the distribution of population (MoH, 2013). The distribution of nurses across the provinces in Indonesia varies, with the greatest population per nurse in areas outside of Java/Bali Island (MoH, 2016b). This data may contrast with doctor distribution, which is preferred to serve in rather than outside Java/Bali Island (MoH, 2016b). The imbalanced distribution of nurses within provinces may be an impact of the decentralisation system, which allows district government to hire health workforce directly (Kurniati & Efendi, 2009, Kurniati et al., 2015). Due to the lack of data, the number of nurses working in rural and urban areas is not available.
In Indonesia, both the government and the private sector provide healthcare. In each province, the government runs the district hospitals and community health centres. At the village level, there are integrated health posts, village midwife clinics and sub-health centres(Kurniati & Efendi, 2013). In addition, there are private hospitals and other Faith-Based Organisations which provide healthcare services (MoH, 2008). The uniqueness of Indonesia’s National Health System (NHS) is the community empowerment pillar. The government views the community itself as a potential asset to be considered in national health development. Health initiatives have been considered as community empowerment in Indonesia, such as Posyandu, an Integrated Health Post based on community to provide healthcare services for maternal and infant healthcare services. At the end of April 2015, there were 289,635Posyandu across Indonesia(MoH, 2015). The diploma and bachelor-trained nurses usually work at hospital and community health centres, while postgraduate degree holders are largely involved in higher-education institutions, although a small number work in health facilities. Table 1 depicts the different nursing education programmes of Indonesia that were registered with the MoEC and their common place of employment.
Table 1. Nursing Programmes in Indonesia
|Nursing program||Eligibility Criteria for Entrance||Training Duration||Examination for qualification||Usually work at|
|Diploma in Nursing||Completion of 12th grade||3 years
|Indonesian Health Worker Assembly (MTKI) with University||Hospital, community health centre|
|Bachelor of Nursing||Completion of 12th grade||4 years in academy
1 year in clinical setting
MTKI with University
|Hospital, community health centre, industry|
|Master of Nursing||Bachelor of Nursing/Registered Nurse||2 years||University||Nursing school, hospital|
|Specialist in Nursing||Master of Nursing||1 year||University||Nursing school, hospital|
|Doctoral in Nursing||Master of Nursing||3 years||University||Nursing school|
Table 2 shows that the number of nurses is greatest at the Diploma 3 level. In recent years, the number of nursing institutions that provide the bachelor degree has increased. Like a mushroom in the rainy season, nursing education institutions are growing rapidly. The latest data showed that there were 332 nursing institutions offering bachelor degrees and 494 nursing institutions providing Diploma 3(Ministry of Education and Culture, 2014). One document noted that this situation is the result of different policies between the MoH and MoEC (AIPNI et al., 2012). Acknowledging that nursing education institutions are growing unmanageable and seeking to control the quality of health study programmes, including nursing, in 2011, the Ministry of Education and Culture decided to suspend the opening of a nursing study programme(MoEC, 2011).
Table 2. Number of nursing study programmes in Indonesia
Nursing Education in Indonesia
The impressive growth in the number of schools for nursing over the past decade has created increased opportunity and high interest in a nursing career. Nursing was established as a profession in Indonesia at a national workshop held in the year 1983. More than three decades later, there is a need for reform in this sector (Nursalam and Efendi, 2008). Responding to this, several types of nursing educational institutions were established. Government act number 60 in the year 1999 indicates that the term ‘higher education’ refers to Academy, Polytechnic, Sekolah Tinggi (School of Health Science), Institute and University (Government of Indonesia, 1999).
Nursing academies (Akademi Keperawatan) became the first higher education institution providing nursing established in Indonesia. This programme is three years in duration (Diploma 3) and the MoEC database shows that 264 nursing academies have been registered across the nation.
Health education institutions other than for medical personnel were grouped into two, Health Polytechnic (Poltekkes) and Non-Health Polytechnic (Non-Poltekkes), with ownership by the district government, military/police and either private or foundation. Poltekkes with nursing programmes can take either three years (Diploma 3) or four years (Diploma 4) to complete. As of December 2012, the number of registered Diploma 4 programmeswas132, while the number of Diploma 3 programmeswas1,082, which consists of 262 study programmesat 38 Poltekkes and 820 Non-Poltekkes institutions (MoH, 2013). The original purpose of the establishment of Diploma 4 was to train nurse educators in preparation for the bachelor degree program. However, after the project had been completed, the Diploma 4 was allowed to stay open in institutions under the MoH. The Association of Indonesian Nurse Education Centre (AINEC) officially announced that it considered in contrary to the spirit of professionalism in nursing (AIPNI et al., 2012).According to figure 1, nursing study programmes account for 58% of all health study programmes under Pol tekkes.
Figure 1. Distribution of study programme in Poltekkes (MoH, 2013)
Sekolah Tinggi (School of Health Science)
Sekolah Tinggi refers to School of Health Sciences (STIKES) or School of Nursing Sciences (STIKPER) and includes 135 institutions. This type of nursing institution offers diploma and a bachelor degree in nursing.
Several institutes have been established to contribute to the national development, and these include the Institute of Health Sciences, of which some also provide a nursing major. According to the MoEC database, there is only one institute recorded in their system, and this offers diploma and bachelor nursing programmes.
Universities offer study programmes in health sciences, including nursing programmes. This type of higher education provides diploma, bachelor, master, specialist and even doctoral degrees in nursing. There are 92universitieswhichoffer a nursing major.
Challenges in Nursing Education in Indonesia
The Indonesian nursing profession faces a complex situation in the post-Millennium Development Goals era. The rollout of UHC in Indonesia allowed nurses to offer an excellent service to clients. Current challenges will focus on the number and quality of Indonesian nurses.
3.5.1 Excess Nursing Education
High unemployment of nurses has been reported within the country, and this situation has been worsened by the low salary of nurses(Efendi, 2005). Published reports from East Java province show that the largest number of unemployed white-collar workers is nurses. The number has reached 12,000 nurses, of which the private labourmarket only absorbed 10% with just 1% absorbed in the government employee sector (Effendi, 2012). As a result, some have turned to overseas or nurse migration (Efendi et al., 2013). Other published data in 2005 showed that there were annual surpluses of more than 15,000 nurses. At that time, the absorption capacity of public providers was 3,000 nurses per year and an additional 2,000 nurses in the private sector. It must be noted that the exact surplus of nurses is unclear due to the lack of reliable human resources information systems. The challenge on data is not a new issue for Indonesia after implementation of the decentralized system (Kurniati et al., 2014). Under decentralization system, the local government do not feel obligated to send the latest data to the central level. In addition, low awareness of local government for sharing data and information to the central might become the problem. An absence of integrated system between ministries and the job market contributed to the chaos in human resource information system. The substantial surpluses will distort health service delivery and the national health system. In terms of prosperity, nurses are also neglected, as their salaries vary from 50 USD per month to 300 USD per month (Depnakertrans, 2010, Gajimu, 2012). This situation may lead to social conflict in the near future if not addressed properly.
Overall, nurses in Indonesia are employed by either the government or the private sector. The government can recruit them as a civil servant, contract worker or special assignment. The nurse can also be employed in private sector as a permanent worker or contract staff. Indonesia is acknowledged as a country having a crisis in the health workforce, including the number and quality of the workforce (World Health Organization, 2006). The MoH underlined this crisis in a white paper which forecast that, by 2014, they would need 60,022 nursing cadre to be deployed in Indonesia’s hospitals and 240,515 nursing personnel to be deployed in Indonesia’s community health centres. However, the limited capacity of government recruitment should be considered. There were more nurses than vacant positions. As a result, nurses were underpaid and the situation was made worse by inadequate enforcement of the minimum regional wage regulation. It is difficult to track valid data of nurses’ unemployment in Indonesia. The authors assume that, in East Java Province, there are 108 nursing institutions, if the number of graduates per institution averages 100 per annum, there would be 10,800 nursing graduates per year in one province alone.
3.5.2 Various levels of education preparation with different quality
The quality of training varies between institutions. The output of each level of education (from diploma (3 and 4), bachelor degree and specialist) needs to be managed properly in facing the future challenges. Moreover, the lack of infrastructure and low level of education of nursing faculty hinders progress. The critical problem is a lack of qualified nursing lecturers. InFigure 2, we can see that the majority of teaching staff have a bachelor degree, the same level as the students they are teaching. This situation may worsen in clinical settings, as most of the clinical instructor’shaveeither a diploma or bachelor degree. Instead of pursuing higher education, nurse educators need to be updatedby joining seminars or conferences in clinical and community settings. Other problems are the variety of nursing graduates’ quality, particularly in less-developed regions. The place of practice is limited by poor infrastructure and lack of professional lecturers. This situation may exist in certain provinces due to the development gap between provinces. The focus of nursing at community and hospital settings will attract more clinical nurse specialists to support the health development. Across the country, there were only 43 hospitals recognised as a teaching hospital established in 2011 (MoEC, 2011), which limits the ability of students to practice in the hospital.
Figure 2. Numbers and proportion of nursing lecturer by level of education (MoEC, 2011)
Curriculum-Based Competency has enriched the curriculum of nursing education in Indonesia since 2008. Currently, the curriculum of bachelor degree consists of 60% core curriculum (87 credits), 20% institutional curriculum (28-29 credits) with the rest being local content; in total, the students have to achieve144-160 credits (Nursalam and Efendi, 2008). The curriculum accommodates the development of a basic professional foundation in nursing, the local content as excellence programme in each institution and a global curriculum. However, in facing the current migration challenges, there may be a need to redesign the curriculum to meet the needs of international recruiters.
THE WAY FORWARD
The need for good planning to harmonisethesupply and demand of Human Resources for Health (HRH) is urgent. HRH planning in Indonesia hasbeen driven by a simple, normatively determined nurse-to-population ratio. This was done by the MoH in supplying the need of national development.TheMoH and MoEChave no legal obligation to consult and coordinate; therefore, the possibility for a mismatch between planning and production remains. Harmonisation between these two stakeholders may strengthen the future supply and demand of the nursing workforce.
One of the biggest challenges facing government is the shortfall of consistent and reliable data. Forecasting future needs requires comprehensive data on the current supply of nurses across the country. There is a contradiction in the current data,which show that an average of 32,461 nurses graduate each year, but, at the same time, show only a small annual increase in the stock of nurses. It is evident that the current information does not record accurately where the nurses go after graduation, whether they serve in the public or private sectors, rural or urban, or any other vital data. The government should give high priority to improving the quality and accuracy of this data in the near future. The role of regulatory bodies in capturing this information through the registration process is important.
International mobility of the nursing cadre from Indonesia is becoming a promising agenda to tackle the domestic situation(Efendi et al., 2017, Efendi et al., 2016). As such, the authors suggest that feasible solution for unemployed or underemployed nurses is sending them to a foreign country by managing migration.Comprehensive migration management starting from the pre-departurestage, immigrations stage and post-migration stage should be accommodated in policy structure. Moreover, we do have a temporary surplus of nurses supply, as reported on the production side.Proper management of international nurse migration by designated stakeholders will lead to strengthening the country’s health system.
Universal Health Coverage (UHC) was launched on the first day of 2014 and has become an important agenda in Indonesia’s development. The need of a responsive HRH by providing a sufficient and qualified number of nurses was noted by the government(MoH, 2012). Several studies mention that an adequate number of health workforce is necessary to achieve the UHC (Campbell et al., 2013; Cometto et al., 2013). The shortage of nurses, as reported by Indonesia’s government, needs to be reviewed carefully and related to the current supply and demand. In considering the existing surplus of nurses within the country, several clear actions must be considered in the near future. The MoEC must tighten the process of new applications for an opening nursing study programme, promote the establishment of an Independent Accreditation Institution and support the visibility of nursing scholars from Indonesia. The MoH must take a lead to ensure accurate, reliable and timely demand and supply data, carry out comprehensive health human resources planning, establish a centralised mechanism to collect and store health personnel data, and implement short-term planning in managing the current migration, if possible, to mitigate the future impact of migration on Indonesia’s health system.Limitation of current study is a lack of the most updated number of nursing graduates over Indonesia as well as the absence of nurses availability data in the job market.
Indonesian nursing education produces more graduates than the industry can absorb, leading to oversupply and unemployment. Meanwhile, nurse shortages will continue to have a potential negative impact on the healthcare delivery to meet the target of UHC. The entry point to solve these problems is stabilising the supply and demand side through an innovative programme, such as upgrading the skills of current supply for exportation. In addition, working with district government to employ nurses under a decentralisation scheme would be a clear option to reduce unemployment issues. Urgent policy intervention is needed in improving data on human resources in nursing to obtain a clear view of supply and demand. Comprehensive assessment of the Indonesian nurses and labour markets need to be considered in the absence of robust and complete data. Beyond the shortage and surplus issue, education, as a first gate to create a competent nursing workforce, must be improved with the primary goal of competing in global labour markets.
AIPNI, PPNI & AIPDIKI (2012). Draft Naskah Akademik Sistem Pendidikan Keperawatan di Indonesia [Draft Manuscript Academic Nursing Education System in Indonesia]. AIPNI-PPNI-AIPDIKI, Jakarta.
Anderson, I., Meliala, A., MarzoekI, P. & Pambudi, E. (2014). The production, distribution, and performance of physicians, nurses, and midwives in Indonesia : an update, Washington, World Bank Group.
Bappeda Jatim (2012). 12 Ribu Perawat Masih Menganggur [12 Thousands Nurses were Unemployed] [Online]. Surabaya: Bappeda Jatim. Retrieved from: http://bappeda.jatimprov.go.id/2012/05/28/12-ribu-perawat-masih-menganggur/
BNP2TKI (2016). Strategi Pemerintah Dalam Meningkatkan Daya Saing Tenaga Keperawatan (Ners) Di Pasar Kerja Luar Negeri [Government Strategy to Improve Competitiveness of Nurses (Ners) In Job Market Overseas]. Jakarta: BNP2TKI.
Boomgaard, P. (1993). The Development Of Colonial Health Care In Java; An Exploratory Introduction. Bijdragen tot de Taal-, Land- en Volkenkunde, 149(1),pp 77-93.
Campbell, J., Buchan, J., Cometto, G., David, B., Dussault, G., Fogstad, H., Fronteira, I., Lozano, R., Nyonator, F. & Pablos-Méndez, A. (2013). Human resources for health and universal health coverage: fostering equity and effective coverage. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 91(11),pp 853-63.
Cometto, G., Boerma, T., Campbell, J., Dare, L. & Evans, T. (2013). The Third Global Forum: framing the health workforce agenda for universal health coverage. The Lancet Global Health, 1(6), e324-e325.
DEPNAKERTRANS 2010. Minimun Regional Wage per Province year 2010.
DJSN & MOH (2012). Peta Jalan Menuju Jaminan Kesehatan [Roadmap Toward Health Coverage]. Jakarta: Kemenkokesra-DJSN-Kemkes.
Efendi, F. (2005). Kesejahteraan Perawat Yang Terabaikan! [Nurses Welfare Ignored!] [Online]. Surabaya: Pioners PSIK FK Unair. Retrieved from: http://ners.unair.ac.id/materikuliah/kesejahteraan_perawat_yang_terabaikan.pdf
Efendi, F., Chen, C. M., Nursalam, N., Indarwati, R. & Ulfiana, E. (2016). Lived experience of Indonesian nurses in Japan: A phenomenological study. Japan Journal of Nursing Science, 13(2),pp 284-93.
EfendI, F., Mackey, T. K., Huang, M. C. & Chen, C. M. (20170. IJEPA: Gray Area for Health Policy and International Nurse Migration. Nursing Ethics, 24(3),pp 313-328.
Efendi, F., Purwaningsih, M., Qur’aniati, N., Kurniati, A., Singka, E. J. & Chen, C.-M. (2013). Return migration of Indonesian nurses from Japan: Where should they go? Journal of Nursing Education and Practice, 3, p154.
Effendi, Z. (2012).Puluhan Ribu Perawat di Jatim Nganggur [Thousands of Nurses were Unemployed in East Java] [Online]. Surabaya: Detik. Retrieved from: http://news.detik.com/surabaya/read/2012/05/27/141819/1925756/466/puluhan-ribu-perawat-di-jatim-nganggur
Fasseur, C. (2000). Ethical policy and economic development: some experiences of the colonial past. Lembaran Sejarah, 3.
Gajimu. (2012).Perawat di Indonesia Hampir Sama Banyaknya dengan Perawat di Rusia [Nurse in Indonesia almost the same number with a nurse in Russia] [Online]. Jakarta: Wage Indicator Network. Retrieved from: http://www.gajimu.com/main/gaji/perbandingan-upah-global/perawat
Government of Indonesia.(1999). Peraturan Pemerintah republik Indonesia Nomor 60 Tahun 1999 Tentang Pendidikan Tinggi. The Republic of Indonesia. Number 60 About Higher Education. SETNEG,60. Jakarta: Setneg.
Kemenkokesra.(2013). Keputusan Menteri Koordinator Bidang Kesejahteraan Rakyat Republik Indonesia Nomor 54 Tahun 2013 Tentang Rencana Pengembangan Tenaga Kesehatan Tahun 2011-2025.Decree of the Coordinating Minister for People’s Welfare of the Republic of Indonesia Number 54 Year 2013 About the Health Manpower Development Plan 2011-2025. Jakarta: Kemenkokesra.
Kurniati, A., Efendi, F. (2012). Kajian Sumber Daya Manusia Kesehatan.Review of Human Resources for Health. Jakarta: Salemba Medika.
Kurniati, A., Efendi, F. (2013). Human Resources for Health Country Profile of Indonesia.New Delhi, WHO South-East Asia Region.
Kurniati, A., Rosskam, E., Afzal, M. M., Suryowinoto, T. B. & Mukti, A. G. (2015). Strengthening Indonesia’s health workforce through partnerships. Public Health, 129,pp 1138-1149.
Kurniati, A., Efendi, F. (2009). Viewing decentralization as an opportunity in improving availability of health workers in underserved areas. 4th Conference of AAAH. Vietnam: Asia Pacific Action Alliance of HRH.
Kurniati, A., Efendi, F. & Yeh, P.M. (2014). Human Resource Development for Health in Indonesia: Challenges of Achieving the Millennium Development Goals. Jurnal Sumber Daya Manusia Kesehatan, 1.
Mboi, N. (2015). Indonesia: On the Way to Universal Health Care. Health Systems & Reform, 1,pp 91-97.
MINISTRY OF EDUCATION AND CULTURE. (2010). Potret Ketersediaan dan Kebutuhan Tenaga Dokter [Portrait of Availability and Demand of Health Workforce] [Online]. Jakarta: Dirjen Dikti-HPEQ Project. Retrieved from: http://hpeq.dikti.go.id/v2/images/Produk/Potret_Ketersediaan_Dan_Kebutuhan_Tenaga_Dokter.pdf
Ministry of Education and Culture. (2014). Pencarian Data Perguruan Tinggi dan Program Studi [Data Search on University and Study Program] [Online]. Jakarta: Ministry of Education and Culture. Retrieved from: https://forlap.dikti.go.id/
Ministry of State Secretariat of The Republic of Indonesia. (2014). Indonesia Profile [Online]. Jakarta: Ministry of State Secretariat of the Republic of Indonesia. Retrieved from: http://www.setneg.go.id/?lang=en
MOEC.(2011). Moratorium Program-Program Studi Bidang Kesehatan [Moratorium Study Program in Health]. Jakarta: Dikti.
MOH(2007). Profil Pengembangan Dan Pemberdayaan Sumberdaya Manusia Kesehatan Tahun 2006 [Profile Development and Empowerment of Human Resources Health Year 2006].BPPSDMK. Jakarta: MoH.
MOH. (2008). Naskah Akademik UU Rumah Sakit [Academic Review on Hospital Law] [Online]. Jakarta: MoH. Retrieved from: http://www.hukor.depkes.go.id/uploads/produk_hukum/Naskah_Akademik_RUU_Rumah_Sakit.pdf
MOH (2011). Data Lulusan Diknakes Poltekkes dan Non-Poltekkes Tahun 2011. [Data Graduates of Diknakes Poltekkes and Non-Poltekkes]. PUSDIKLATNAKES. Jakarta: BPPSDMK.
MOH (2012). Roadmap Pengembangan dan Pemberdayaan SDM Kesehatan untuk Mendukung Kepesertaan Menyeluruh Program Jaminan Kesehatan Indonesia [Roadmap of the Development and Empowerment of HRH to Support Universal Coverage of Health Insurance Program in Indonesia]. BPPSDMK. Jakarta: MoH.
MOH (2013). Profil Kesehatan Indonesia 2012 [Indonesia Health Profile Year 2012]. 1, I. Jakarta: MoH.
MOH (2014)a. Pemenuhan Tenaga Kesehatan Dalam Jaminan Kesehatan SJSN [Health Workers Availability in Health Isurance SJSN]. BPPSDMK. Jakarta: BPPSDMK.
MOH (2014)b. Pendataan SDM Kesehatan yang didayagunakan pada Fasilitas Pelayanan Kesehatan (Fasyankes) di Indonesia [Registration of Health human resources utilized on health care services in Indonesia] [Online]. Jakarta: BPPSDM-MoH.
MOH (2015). Data dan Informasi Tahun 2014 (Profil Kesehatan Indonesia) [Data and Information in 2014 (Health Profile of Indonesia)]. KEMENKES, P. D. D. I. Jakarta: Kemenkes.
MOH (2016)a. Data Keadaan Tenaga Keperawatan [Data on Situation of Nursing Workforce] [Online]. Jakarta: Kementerian Kesehatan. Retrieved from: http://bppsdmk.kemkes.go.id/info_sdmk/info/index.php?pil=3
MOH (2016)b. Profil Kesehatan Indonesia 2015 [Indonesia Health Profile Year 2015], Jakarta, MoH.
Nursalam& Efendi, F. (2008). Pendidikan Dalam Keperawatan [Education in Nursing].Jakarta, Salemba Medika.
Schoute, D. (1937). Occidental therapeutics in the netherlands east indies during three centuries of netherlands settlement. (1600-1900),Batavia, G Kolff & Co. Schulte Nordholt NG.
Spetz, J. (2011). Unemployed and Underemployed Nurses [Online]. Switzerland: ICN. Retrieved from: http://www.nurse.or.jp/nursing/international/icn/report/pdf/2012/02-04-2.pdf
Speybroeck, N., Kinfu, Y., DalPoz, M. R. & Evans, D. B. (2006). Reassessing the relationship between human resources for health, intervention coverage and health outcomes. Geneva: World Health Organization.
Statistics Indonesia – Badan Pusat Statistik – Bps, National Population, Family Planning Board – Bkkbn/Indonesia, Kementerian Kesehatan – Kemenkes – Ministry of Health/Indonesia & Icf International (2013). Indonesia Demographic and Health Survey 2012, Jakarta, BPS, BKKBN, Kemenkes, and ICF International.
Suara Surabaya. (2013). 12 Ribu Perawat di Jatim Masih Menganggur [12 Thousands Nurses in Jatim were Unemployed] [Online]. Surabaya: Suara Surabaya. Retrieved from:http://m.suarasurabaya.net/kelanakota/detail.php?id=78661b21f156a47d1500242e6b1dd7cc2012106782
Suwandono, A., Muharso, M., Achadi, A. & Aryastami, K. (2005). Human Resources On Health (HRH) For Foreign Countries: A Case Of Nurse ‘Surplus’ In Indonesia. Asia Pacific Action Alliance of Human Resources for Health. Srilanka: AAAH.
World Bank.(1993). World Development Report 1993: Investing in Health.New York, Oxford University Press.
World Health Organization (2006). The world health report 2006: working together for health.Geneva, World Health Organization.
World Health Organization. (2014). Global Health Workforce Statistics database [Online]. Geneva: World Health Organization. Retrieved from: http://www.who.int/hrh/statistics/hwfstats/
How to attract health students to remote areas in Indonesia: a discrete choice experiment